Also another heads up for the nrf antenna. They seemed to be defective so the seller told me this.
Thanks for heads up, I was just going to order it haha;) maybe that’s why @solidgeek had slight issues with them.
@wmj259 Well if thats the case… I found another seller on Aliexpress - I have replaced the link in the parts list and bought a few myself to test.
@MontPierre Slight issues? My head is gonna explode… I can’t seem to get a stable connection with the current nRF24 modules. It is very sensitive, and the range is no more than 1.5 meters. I am thinking of pulling out the nRF24 module from my old remote, and use it instead, as that module surely did work. However I still have to find a good supplier of nRF24 modules. I am waiting for the ones from Aliexpress.
It seems that nRF24 modules from china mostly are crap 
1 Like
Looks like an awesome remote, might try it out myself if my Bad Wolf starts having problems. I’m curious though as to why you used the NRF module over something like an ESP that can also serve as the MCU so you can ditch the Arduino.
1 Like
I’ve asked others about this too but haven’t seen much about doing ad-hoc with the ESP chips since they’re usually used on wifi (at least from what I’ve seen on the youtubes). I do think a single board with the radio and mcu would be ideal I basically made a PCB that just connects the two boards but it’s a fat sandwich compared to baking all the smd components onto a single board. Problem is the cost to get the chips and assembly done is high unless you’re making a bazillion of them (at least a few thousand) so it’s hard to justify doing a total custom board, @Sander did a custom nrf board design but costs are way higher for small batches.
Pretty sure the way the ad-hoc works with the ESP chips is the same as the particle photon boards where one has to be setup to be an access point and the other one connects to it https://community.particle.io/t/multi-device-talking-possible/13373/7 Honestly not sure if this is better or worse than the “burst-packet” technology the nrf modules use for point to point communication but feels sort of like shoehorning it with the ESP chips if you’re making a mobile access point (on the plus side I suppose multiple devices could connect to it but that must have overhead to it).
About the range in a clear line of site you’ll get about 3-4 meters of connection before it loses it completely on low power mode, if you add the capacitor on the gnd and vcc and jack up the power to max with the chips I have can broadcast at least a half a block away.
Definitely one of those components that is notorious for being cloned, honestly didn’t check the stamp with a magnifying lens or anything to see if it was genuine but haven’t really had problems outside of my own errors.
These are the ones I’ve been using:
1 Like
I finally got it working! The problem wasn’t the actual transmission, but instead the auto-acknowledgement. The remote uses the auto-ack feature of the nRF24 to know if the transmission was a succes or not, however I had not taken into consideration that a transmission could be succesfull even though the auto-ack wasn’t recieved probably.
And it seems that the nRF24 modules weren’t to blame, but instead the poor quality of my Arduino Nanos 3.3V output. Apparently the clones that are being sold on Ebay etc. comes with a very poor 3.3V regulator, that causes a lot of electronic noise - some worse than others. The noise/voltage ripples can make signal distorted and therefore not getting to the remote.
I solved this by adding a 220uF cap on the 3.3V rail, and adding a 47uF on the nRF24 modules (soldered it directly to the pins). This however didn’t solve the issue completly, I had to make some software changes on the receiver, and now the remote works perfectly with a distance of +8 meters.
I will update the software on githup tonight and finish the schematics as soon as I can 
@JdogAwesome Thanks ! I have choosen to use nRF24 module, because they are power efficient, and easy to get and use. The idea of the remote, was that anyone with a little DIY-skills should be able to make one by themself, and therefore I believe that an Arduino and the nRF24 modules are a perfect match
9 Likes
Why go through this trouble with the NRF when you can use bluetooth module? Isn’t it much simpler?
1 Like
No not really the pairing is also a pita typically and the hc-05 or hc-06 chips are still more than the nrf chips. I used one and controlled from an app on my phone but would recommend against it. With a controller instead of phone as controller it might be better but still don’t see the advantage over the nrf chips.
Also I use Bluetooth for headphones and Android is crappy enough at A2DP or whatever it’s using that I don’t really trust all the extra noise that will make (maybe unjustified fear but there nonetheless)
@Snowi Bluetooth was also my first thought! However I read many places that Bluetooth 2.0 (HC-05 etc) aren’t that reliable to use for critical applications such as Esk8 at high speeds in crowded cities - your life is at stake 
. In addition, Bluetooth doesn’t really have any advantages, except that it is (in my experience) easier to work with. Maybe a newer version of Bluetooth (3.0, 4.0) would be more reliable in the future? For the moment I think nRF24 will do 
@wafflejock I agree
I just found this PCB, with a built-in charger and boost converter! Seems very nice, and fits perfectly (with extra room) next to the battery in the remote. It does not have a built-in over-discharge protection, however, the battery I am using has - so no problem.
This seems a lot easier than using two different modules, it would make the assembly process much easier at least
2 Likes
Are you planning any design changes in the near future ? Just wanted a heads up if you do and before I start printing it.
2 Likes
Yes I am planning to make a hole for leash attachment, and adding a 3D-model for the receiver too If you don’t need leash, well there will be no changes to the remote design at the moment
Thanks mate ! I’ll be waiting on that leash hole then haha. Are you going to finalize the BOM and a step by step guide anytime soon ?
Yes I am I am currently working on a wiki/guide on github, I hope that will do 
maybe I will make an instructables later.
4 Likes
how about this one. it has micro usb interface.
It’s basically the same I used in my current remote build, however it is only a charger nothing more (you will need a boost converter board too). The micro USB has to be removed anyway, as the charging port is placed next to the switch, and it can’t fit attached to the board.
5 Likes
ok, thanks.
I just found another one which fits (with over-discharge protection). I will order a few of both boards and test them out as soon as they arrive (usually two weeks).
Charger and boost module (over discharge protection): $3,79
Charger and boost module (no over discharge protection): $3,18
2 Likes
Håber du poster dit projekt i FB gruppen, når du er i mål Jeg vil i hvertfald bygge din remote, men venter med at bestille noget, til du har låst dit på de forskellige komponenter